Updated 3/6/25
Scotiabank, officially known as The Bank of Nova Scotia, is one of Canada’s largest and most established financial institutions. With a presence spanning over 50 countries, it stands out among the “Big Five” Canadian banks, particularly for its international reach in Latin America and the Caribbean.
For dividend investors, the appeal of BNS is easy to see. It offers a high dividend yield, a long history of consistent payouts, and a solid reputation for financial stability. But with earnings under pressure and a payout ratio that seems stretched, is this bank still a reliable dividend investment? Let’s take a closer look at what’s really going on.
Key Dividend Metrics
📌 Forward Dividend Yield: 6.14% 🏦 (A strong income play, but is it sustainable?)
📌 Trailing Dividend Yield: 8.73% 💰 (Higher than usual—temporary or concerning?)
📌 5-Year Average Dividend Yield: 5.72% 📈 (Suggests the current yield is higher than normal.)
📌 Annual Dividend Payout: $2.98 per share 📅 (Good cash flow potential, but future growth is uncertain.)
📌 Payout Ratio: 87.42% ⚠️ (On the higher side for a bank, which raises red flags.)
📌 Dividend Growth: Historically steady, but recent trends show more caution
Dividend Overview
BNS is a name that many dividend investors recognize for its long-standing commitment to payouts. Right now, the stock boasts a dividend yield of over 6%, which is significantly higher than what most major North American banks offer. That alone makes it an attractive option for those looking for steady income.
However, high yields aren’t always a good thing. A yield that stretches too far above historical norms can sometimes be a warning sign, signaling underlying financial challenges. The company’s payout ratio, sitting at over 87%, is a key metric to watch. When a bank distributes that much of its earnings in dividends, it leaves little room for reinvestment or cushioning during economic downturns.
Earnings have also taken a hit, with a sharp 47% year-over-year decline in quarterly profits. That doesn’t mean an immediate dividend cut is on the horizon, but it does indicate that BNS will need to turn things around to keep its generous payouts flowing long-term.
Dividend Growth and Safety
Dividend investors don’t just look for high yields—they want to know that payouts will grow over time. Historically, Scotiabank has been reliable in this area, gradually increasing its dividend year after year.
The good news is that the company still generates strong operating cash flows, bringing in over $13 billion in the past year. That helps support dividend payments, even when earnings fluctuate.
The concern, however, is the combination of a high payout ratio and declining earnings. If profits continue to slide, it could put pressure on management to slow dividend growth or even pause hikes altogether.
For now, the dividend remains intact, but investors should keep an eye on whether earnings recover in the coming quarters. If the payout ratio creeps even higher, it may indicate that the current dividend level isn’t sustainable over the long term.
Chart Analysis
Overall Trend
The chart for The Bank of Nova Scotia (BNS) shows a clear shift in momentum over the past several months. After a strong rally in the second half of last year, the stock has entered a downtrend, breaking below key support levels. The most noticeable shift has been in the moving averages—what was once a bullish setup has now flipped, with the 50-day moving average rolling over and heading downward, crossing below the 200-day moving average in what traders call a death cross. This signals a potential change in trend, with sellers now in control.
Moving Averages
The 50-day moving average (orange line) was acting as support during the stock’s strong uptrend but has now started to decline, reflecting weakening momentum. The price is currently below both the 50-day and 200-day moving averages, which suggests a bearish bias. The 200-day moving average (blue line) is still pointing slightly upward, but if the price continues to stay below this level, it could eventually flatten or even turn down.
Volume Activity
Volume tells a story of its own. There was a spike in selling volume around mid-February, coinciding with the breakdown below key support levels. This suggests that institutional investors or large traders were offloading shares. More recently, volume has tapered off, which may indicate a temporary pause in selling, but there hasn’t been a clear sign of buyers stepping in aggressively.
RSI and Momentum
The Relative Strength Index (RSI), shown at the bottom of the chart, is heading lower, indicating weakening momentum. It hasn’t reached extreme oversold levels yet, but it’s getting close. If the RSI drops below 30, it would suggest that the stock is oversold, which sometimes leads to a short-term bounce. However, just because something is oversold doesn’t mean it will immediately recover—stocks can stay in these conditions for extended periods in a strong downtrend.
Recent Candles and Price Action
The last five trading days paint a picture of continued weakness. The candles show lower highs and lower lows, a sign that sellers are still dominant. The wicks on the daily candles don’t show significant rejection of lower prices, which means there hasn’t been a strong push from buyers trying to reverse the trend. The stock recently closed at $48.17, just barely above its session low of $47.95, suggesting weak demand at these levels.
Analyst Ratings
📈 Upgrades:
- Canaccord Genuity: On November 19, 2024, Canaccord Genuity upgraded BNS from a hold to a buy rating, increasing the price target from C$71.00 to C$84.00. The upgrade was based on the bank’s solid financial performance and its potential for growth in international markets.
- Bank of America: On the same day, Bank of America shifted its rating from neutral to buy, setting a price target of C$90.00. Analysts cited the bank’s strong capital position and diversified revenue streams as key reasons for the upgrade.
📉 Downgrades:
- CIBC: On February 18, 2025, CIBC downgraded BNS from outperform to neutral, lowering the price target from C$84.00 to C$81.00. Analysts expressed concerns over the bank’s exposure to international markets and the potential impact on its profit margins.
- Jefferies Financial Group: Also on February 18, 2025, Jefferies reduced its price target for BNS from C$81.00 to C$77.00, reflecting a more cautious stance on the bank’s earnings growth amid economic uncertainties.
📊 Consensus Price Target: As of March 5, 2025, analysts maintain a Hold rating on BNS, with an average 12-month price target of approximately C$78.55, indicating a potential upside of about 14% from the current share price.
These mixed ratings highlight the divided outlook on BNS, with some analysts seeing upside potential based on its long-term fundamentals, while others remain cautious due to near-term earnings pressures and global market exposure.
Earnings Report Summary
Scotiabank’s latest earnings report revealed a mixed performance, with some strong areas of growth but also notable challenges. The bank reported net income of $993 million for the first quarter of 2025, a decline from $2.2 billion in the same period last year. This drop was largely attributed to an impairment charge related to its investment in the Bank of Xi’an in China, which significantly impacted overall profits.
On an adjusted basis, the bank’s earnings came in at $2.2 billion, or $1.76 per share. A bright spot in the report was a 15% increase in noninterest revenue, fueled by strong results in Global Wealth Management and Global Banking and Markets. Global Wealth Management earnings rose to $414 million, with assets under administration reaching an impressive $730 billion. Meanwhile, Global Banking and Markets saw a 33% year-over-year increase, largely driven by a 54% boost from capital markets activities.
Scotiabank also strengthened its financial position, improving its capital ratio by 140 basis points since the end of 2022. The bank added $1.6 billion in allowances for credit losses, demonstrating a conservative approach in managing potential risks. In addition, deposit growth of 4% year-over-year helped improve the bank’s liquidity, bringing its loan-to-deposit ratio down to 105%.
Despite these positive developments, some areas struggled. The Canadian Banking division faced pressure from higher credit provisions, which weighed on earnings. Provisions for credit losses rose to C$1.16 billion, reflecting a more cautious stance in response to economic uncertainties and potential risks in the loan portfolio.
International Banking delivered more encouraging results, showing diversified revenue growth and an improved productivity ratio of 51%. The bank has also been making strategic moves to strengthen its presence in North America, including acquiring a 14.9% stake in U.S. regional lender KeyCorp, signaling an effort to expand its reach in the U.S. market.
Overall, the earnings report presents a mixed picture—certain business segments are showing strength, while others face headwinds from economic conditions and credit risk. The bank’s ability to navigate these challenges while maintaining steady revenue growth will be key in the coming quarters.
Financial Health and Stability
Scotiabank remains one of Canada’s top banks, but its recent financial performance suggests some challenges ahead.
- Revenue: $28.86 billion over the last 12 months, but down 8.3% year-over-year
- Profit Margin: 23.32%, indicating a solid but declining level of profitability
- Return on Equity (ROE): 8.01%, which is lower than its Canadian banking peers
- Total Cash Reserves: $444 billion, giving the bank a sizable cushion
- Total Debt: $289 billion, a manageable level for a bank of this size
While the bank still holds a strong balance sheet, its profitability has taken a hit. The lower ROE suggests that BNS is not generating as much return on shareholder equity as some of its competitors. This could be due to its greater exposure to international markets, which sometimes come with higher risks and volatility.
For investors, the main takeaway here is that BNS remains financially solid but faces profitability challenges that could affect future dividend decisions.
Valuation and Stock Performance
Scotiabank’s stock is trading in the middle of its 52-week range, reflecting a mix of both concerns and opportunities.
- Current Price-to-Earnings (P/E) Ratio: 14.42 (somewhat high for a bank)
- Forward P/E Ratio: 10.01 (indicating potential earnings recovery)
- Price-to-Book (P/B) Ratio: 1.17 (fairly valued, but lower than historical levels)
- 52-Week Range: $43.68 to $57.07
On a valuation basis, the stock doesn’t look particularly expensive, but it’s also not trading at a deep discount. Investors who are confident in an earnings rebound may find it attractively priced, while those concerned about ongoing profitability issues may want to wait for a clearer turnaround.
Risks and Considerations
While Scotiabank has been a reliable dividend payer for years, no investment comes without risks. Here are a few key factors to keep in mind:
- Economic Slowdowns: Banks are highly sensitive to interest rates and economic conditions. A weaker economy could lead to lower loan demand and higher defaults.
- Dividend Payout Ratio: At 87%, the bank is using a large portion of its earnings for dividends. If profits don’t stabilize, there could be pressure to adjust the payout.
- International Exposure: While its operations in Latin America and the Caribbean provide growth opportunities, they also come with currency risks and political uncertainty.
- Earnings Volatility: A 47% drop in quarterly earnings is significant. If this trend continues, it could impact investor confidence and stock performance.
Investors who prioritize dividend safety over high yield should watch earnings trends closely. If profitability remains under pressure, it could impact the bank’s ability to maintain its current payout levels.
Final Thoughts
Scotiabank has long been a favorite among dividend investors, and for good reason. Its strong cash flow and long history of payouts make it an appealing choice for income-focused portfolios.
At the same time, the bank faces real challenges. Earnings are under pressure, and the payout ratio is getting uncomfortably high. While there’s no immediate threat to the dividend, future growth may be more limited unless profits start to recover.
For those looking for steady income, BNS remains a viable option. But investors should go in with their eyes open, understanding that the combination of high yield and earnings pressure makes this a stock to monitor closely. The next few quarters will be key in determining whether BNS continues to be one of the best dividend plays in the banking sector—or if investors should start looking elsewhere.
Recent Comments