Updated 6/2/25
Merchants Bancorp (MBIN) is a regional financial institution with a sharp focus on multifamily and healthcare lending, warehouse financing, and mortgage banking. Headquartered in Indiana, the company has built a reputation for strong credit discipline and an efficient balance sheet. With a current share price around $32 and a price-to-earnings ratio under 6, it’s trading at a valuation that reflects caution, despite consistently high returns on equity and growing core deposits.
Recent Events
Merchants Bancorp has had a bit of a rollercoaster ride lately. The first quarter of 2025 brought a noticeable drop in earnings, with net income falling to $58.2 million. That’s quite a dip compared to both the previous quarter and the same time last year. Earnings per share came in at $0.93, which is down almost 50% year-over-year. Not exactly the kind of start investors hoped for, but there’s some context here.
The softness was mostly due to market headwinds that delayed loan originations. On top of that, fair value adjustments to the company’s servicing rights and derivatives knocked about five cents off the bottom line. That said, management has made it clear these are timing-related issues rather than structural weaknesses.
Despite the earnings hiccup, Merchants still looks pretty solid under the hood. The company’s balance sheet shows $4.7 billion in untapped borrowing capacity — that’s about a quarter of total assets — so liquidity is strong. Total assets also climbed to $18.8 billion, up 5% from the year prior. Most encouragingly for long-term investors, the tangible book value per share reached an all-time high of $34.90, up 19% year-over-year. So while short-term profitability took a hit, the overall foundation remains sturdy.
Key Dividend Metrics
-
🏦 Dividend Yield: 1.25%
-
💰 Annual Dividend: $0.40 per share
-
📅 Ex-Dividend Date: June 13, 2025
-
🗓️ Payment Date: July 1, 2025
-
🧮 Payout Ratio: 7.36%
-
📈 1-Year Dividend Growth: 11.76%
-
📊 5-Year Dividend Growth: 13.87%
-
🔄 Dividend Increase Frequency: 5 increases in 5 years
Dividend Overview
Merchants Bancorp might not be throwing off eye-popping yields, but its dividend story is quietly compelling. The bank is currently paying out $0.40 per share annually, translating to a 1.25% yield. While that yield might not turn heads on its own, the consistency and health behind it are what make it interesting.
The payout ratio is just 7.36%, which is extremely conservative. That means Merchants is holding onto the bulk of its earnings — something dividend investors should appreciate. It signals both prudence and the potential for more generous dividends down the road if management decides to open the spigot a little more.
Over the past five years, the bank has increased its dividend five times. That kind of consistency stands out, especially in a sector where some players tend to hold dividends steady or cut them when the going gets tough. The dividend growth rate over that period? A respectable 13.87% annually. That shows a genuine commitment to rewarding shareholders.
Dividend Growth and Safety
One of the best things about Merchants Bancorp’s dividend is how well-covered it is. With a payout ratio hovering around 7%, the dividend isn’t stretching the company’s resources. It’s a small slice of earnings, which leaves plenty of room for operational flexibility and reinvestment in the business.
Beyond just the numbers, the overall financial picture supports the safety of the dividend. Liquidity is high, with billions available in unused borrowing capacity. In simple terms, the company isn’t going to be caught scrambling for cash anytime soon.
And then there’s the strength of the balance sheet. Tangible book value per share has climbed significantly, hitting a record high recently. That speaks to underlying asset growth and careful capital management — two traits that bode well for maintaining and even increasing dividend payouts over time.
So while Merchants may not be the flashiest dividend stock out there, the foundation is strong, the growth is consistent, and the safety margin is wide. For investors who value reliability and a growing income stream, those traits are worth paying attention to.
Cash Flow Statement
Merchants Bancorp’s trailing 12-month cash flow picture paints a clear picture of a company navigating a volatile interest rate and credit environment with significant financial activity. Operating cash flow came in at negative $303.5 million, a meaningful improvement from the previous year’s deeper negative figure but still firmly in the red. This marks the third consecutive year of negative operating cash flow, reflecting the capital-intensive nature of the bank’s operations and the timing of earnings relative to cash movements. Free cash flow, which adjusts for capital expenditures, also remains negative at approximately $326.4 million.
On the investing side, outflows remained substantial at $180.2 million, but this is actually a massive drop from over $3 billion in the prior year—likely tied to a pullback in securities purchases or loan originations. Financing cash flow told a more upbeat story, bringing in $496.2 million. This inflow continues a consistent trend for Merchants, largely driven by ongoing debt issuance activity to support growth. The bank’s ability to access capital markets remains strong, and its end cash position improved modestly to $521.3 million, signaling decent liquidity despite the operational cash burn.
Analyst Ratings
📉 Merchants Bancorp has seen a notable change in analyst sentiment recently. One research firm downgraded the stock from a “hold” to a “sell,” primarily due to concerns surrounding its underwhelming Q1 earnings. The downgrade reflects broader unease about the bank’s ability to maintain momentum in a tricky interest rate environment. With the most recent results falling short of expectations, some analysts are clearly moving to the sidelines.
🧐 Still, not all the commentary has been negative. Raymond James maintained its “outperform” rating but trimmed its price target from $45 to $41, a move that shows tempered optimism. Morgan Stanley stayed neutral, keeping its “equal weight” rating while adjusting its target down slightly from $47 to $45. In contrast, Piper Sandler took a more upbeat stance, raising their target from $52.50 to $56.50, pointing to confidence in the bank’s long-term fundamentals and capital position.
📊 Across the board, the consensus rating on MBIN stands at “Moderate Buy.” The average 12-month price target now sits at $47.50. That’s a potential upside of roughly 48% from the recent trading level near $32. Price targets range from $41 on the low end to $56.50 at the high end, showing a healthy divergence in opinion, but generally leaning toward cautious optimism.
Earning Report Summary
Slower Start to the Year
Merchants Bancorp’s first quarter of 2025 came in a little softer than investors have been used to. Net income landed at $58.2 million, which was down compared to both the previous quarter and the same time last year. Earnings per share slipped to $0.93 from $1.80 a year ago. The drop wasn’t exactly unexpected—management pointed to delays in loan originations and conversions, which made it harder to recognize gains from loan sales and compressed the net interest margin.
These challenges stem largely from broader uncertainty in the market, especially around interest rates and borrower behavior. It’s worth noting that this isn’t about credit quality or operational missteps. It’s more a matter of timing, with fewer loans moving through the pipeline in the quarter than usual.
Leadership’s Take
Even with the dip in earnings, the tone from leadership was far from worried. CEO Michael Petrie acknowledged the short-term drag but was quick to highlight the strength of the loan pipeline and the bank’s position to benefit as conditions normalize. He emphasized that the slowdown doesn’t reflect a change in customer demand—just delays.
President and COO Michael Dunlap struck a similar note. He talked about the bank’s ongoing investment in operations and staying focused on long-term strategy, even in quarters where results don’t pop. Both leaders came across as confident that the fundamentals remain in place for growth.
Strong Underlying Fundamentals
Under the surface, some important metrics tell a more positive story. Tangible book value per share reached a new high of $34.90, a sign that the bank is managing capital efficiently. Total assets rose 5% year-over-year, now standing at $18.8 billion. Core deposits also climbed, now making up 86% of all deposits—something the bank hasn’t seen since early 2022.
Not everything was perfect, though. Non-performing loans increased to $284.6 million, or about 2.73% of loans receivable. This was mainly due to borrowers in the multi-family and healthcare sectors dealing with variable-rate loans that have become more expensive. The bank has credit protection in place on over $2 billion in loans, so it’s taking steps to stay ahead of any potential credit issues.
All in all, the quarter showed some friction in the numbers, but the message from leadership was clear—they’re not rattled. Merchants continues to operate from a position of strength, and while Q1 brought some headwinds, there’s confidence that the year has room to pick up from here.
Management Team
Merchants Bancorp is led by a team of seasoned professionals who bring both depth and continuity to the bank’s leadership. At the top is Michael Dunlap, who serves as President and CEO. He’s been a driving force behind the bank’s strategic vision and has helped shape its growth across key sectors like multifamily lending and warehouse financing. With decades of industry experience, Dunlap combines deep operational knowledge with a forward-thinking approach that continues to guide the bank through evolving market conditions.
The financial side of the house is managed by CFO Sean Sievers. He’s known for his strong analytical mindset and has played a crucial role in ensuring the bank maintains a disciplined balance sheet. His leadership in risk controls and capital efficiency has been a stabilizing influence during periods of interest rate volatility. Supporting them is a cohesive group of senior executives overseeing areas like credit, operations, compliance, and investor relations—many of whom have been with the bank through multiple growth phases. Together, they’ve fostered a culture that’s both performance-driven and risk-aware, with a clear focus on long-term sustainability.
Valuation and Stock Performance
Shares of Merchants Bancorp are currently trading around $32.02, putting the company’s market cap at about $1.47 billion. When you compare this price with its trailing twelve-month earnings per share of $5.44, the stock is trading at a price-to-earnings ratio just under 6. That’s low, especially for a bank that continues to post double-digit returns on equity. The market appears to be pricing in caution rather than rewarding the strong fundamentals, which is typical in uncertain credit cycles.
Looking at its historical stock performance, MBIN has slipped roughly 20% over the past year. That underperformance relative to broader benchmarks may have less to do with the company’s internal performance and more to do with overall concerns in the regional banking space. Investors have been particularly wary of banks with sizable exposure to real estate and rate-sensitive lending.
That said, analyst sentiment is fairly constructive. The current consensus 12-month price target sits at $47.50, which suggests nearly 48% upside from current levels. There’s a range of price targets between $41 and $56.50, indicating varied expectations but generally pointing toward recovery. The valuation multiples—paired with a strong capital base and healthy earnings—paint a picture of a stock that’s been overlooked more than overvalued.
Risks and Considerations
No investment comes without risk, and Merchants Bancorp is no exception. The bank has grown aggressively in sectors like healthcare and multifamily lending. While those areas have contributed to strong asset growth, they also bring elevated risk, especially as interest rates remain high and refinancing activity slows. Higher borrowing costs could increase stress on loan performance, particularly for variable-rate borrowers in capital-intensive sectors.
Another area to watch is credit quality. The most recent quarter saw an uptick in non-performing loans, which now represent just under 3% of total loans. This is still within manageable limits, but it’s a trend worth monitoring. The bank has implemented credit protection strategies, including guarantees and third-party risk-sharing, but macroeconomic pressures could still challenge underwriting assumptions.
Regulatory oversight is another factor. As the bank expands and engages in more complex loan structures, it faces a higher level of scrutiny. New compliance burdens could impact operational agility or lead to unexpected costs. And while Merchants has been successful at raising capital when needed, future financing could become more expensive if investor sentiment doesn’t recover.
Final Thoughts
Merchants Bancorp remains an interesting name within the regional banking space. Its fundamentals are solid, the management team has a long track record of smart execution, and the valuation looks attractive on a number of traditional metrics. Book value is rising, core deposits are sticky, and the bank continues to generate impressive returns on assets and equity.
Still, it’s a stock that’s operating under a cloud of broader industry caution. For those comfortable navigating some sector-level uncertainty, Merchants offers both value and income, supported by a very low payout ratio and a history of consistent dividend growth. Whether the market is ready to reward those traits may depend more on macro conditions than anything company-specific, but the groundwork for long-term performance is clearly in place.